Wednesday, December 2, 2009

The Best Chorus Song Ever!

December 1, 2009 -- For the past fifty years, the Barbershop Harmony Society's International chorus competition has displayed countless performances that we would consider monumental in the influence towards the artistic direction of our art form. Some of these songs helped choruses earn the title "International Champion" while others broadened our creativity to help bring more diversity to the contest stage. YouBarbershop has set out to decide which song has had the largest impact on our barbershop culture. There are dozens of performances that could be considered influential in our art form so YouBarbershop has decided to narrow the list of songs to just eight. However, you will have a voice in the final selection!



Here are your eight nominated songs:


Seventy-six Trombones- Ambassadors of Harmony (2009-1st) Taking down the thirty year reigning champion Vocal Majority is no easy task to accomplish. However, the Ambassadors of Harmony armed themselves with a spectacular uptune, showcasing over a hundred musical instruments, tear away uniforms, an International quartet champion cameo (Vocal Spectrum) and some clean singing to boot! Earlier in the day, the Vocal Majority had received the highest score ever given in a barbershop competition.  A few hours later the Ambassadors broke the new record and it took three 100 scores in the Presentation category and another 100 score in Singing to do it!


Strike Up The Band- Westminster (2007-1st) Having come in second place to the Vocal Majority the previous year everyone was expecting something special from the youthful Westminster chorus. The reward to the audience was an energetic performance beginning with the intro when the chorus members formed into a giant "W." However, one of the coolest moments was when the chorus simulated a twenty second drumline stomp using their hands and feet. The audience was enthralled by this unique performance. However, the judges did penalize the rhythmic beat for being too long without singing and almost cost them the contest. Tying for first place with the Ambassadors of Harmony, Westminster edged them out in the Singing category. Their win has aided in the youth movement with more and more chapters forming across our Society.



Song For The Little Guy- Toronto Northern Lights (2003-2nd) Toronto Northern Lights came on the scene back in 2000 as one of the successful small chorus clones to the Louisville Times. With only 46 men on stage, TNL was competing against choruses well over a hundred men and multiple gold medal championships. In Montreal, TNL competed against the Vocal Majority and decided this year to have some fun with the premise that "size doesn't matter." With clever lyrics and a fantastic arrangement by David Wright, TNL entertained the audience with humor and A+ singing. One of the funniest gags was when a twenty foot giant peeks his head over the riser shell and later gets taken down by David with a small pebble. Other "small in size" gags included making fun of Gas House Gang, goldfish starring at Sea World and Canada being "the leader of the free world." TNL proved comedians can make people both laugh and be blown away by quality singing at the same time.



Here Comes The Showboat- Masters of Harmony (2002-1st) Having dealt with three director changes within a six year period, barbershoppers were not sure what to expect from the three time International Champions. What the MOH gave was perhaps one of the most complete performances on a contest stage with their rendition of "Here Comes The Showboat." The song opened with a story about the "vessels of dreams" that brought shows and performers to your town. Once the boat arrives on shore the chorus breaks into the actual show that includes banjo players, jugglers, dancers and hand-bone performers. But the biggest surprise came when a quartet (International champion Nightlife) stepped out front and sang a couple bars without the chorus. This is the first time a quartet has ever competed in a chorus competition! Immediately following the quartet was the chorus singing a loud and impactful "EVERYBODY HARMONIZE!" which just knocked you out of your seat. The tag ended with the chorus mimicking a giant paddlewheel. A complete set from beginning to end, "Showboat" helped to stabilized everyone's opinions that the MOH would continue to bring musical excellence to our contest stages.


Brother, Can You Spare A Dime- Toronto Northern Lights (2001-2nd) In 2001, Toronto Northern Lights took theatrics and character study to a whole new level when they performed "Brother, Can You Spare A Dime?" It wasn't just the polished, musical execution that helped them earn their first silver medal, but the emotional impact between audience and performer that raised the bar of musical excellence on the International stage. In order to achieve that emotional believability, the chorus members were asked by its leadership to dress down and go out on the streets of Toronto to beg for money. The rule was they were not allowed to stop begging until someone literally gives them a dime. Many chorus members were surprised how difficult it was to receive just one dime from a stranger. One member in particular decided he would try and beg for enough money to feed his baby. It took him all day to finally raise six dollars so he could buy formula for his child. The members saved their dimes and had them pinned inside their costumes as a reminder of their efforts.



Love Me And The World Is Mine- Masters of Harmony (1996-1st) Coming off two successive wins in 1990 and 1993, the Masters of Harmony still felt they had something to prove within the barbershop world. Their first win in 1990 resulted in a tie with the Louisville Thoroughbreds which was broken in the Sound Category by a mere six points. In 1993, they beat the emotional soldier performance of The New Tradition Chorus by 29 points, however many felt it could have gone either way. Between 1993 and 1996 the MOH worked hard at raising the talent level as well as higher musical expectations from its membership. There was also a lot of talk behind the scenes that this could be Dr. Greg Lyne's last competition as the musical director of the Masters. The song "Love Me And The World Is Mine" was arranged by David Wright and was the epitome of "power ballads." Rallying the troops was not a difficult task and the focus at rehearsals was intense. However the hard work paid off. Earlier in the competition, TNT had an electric performance doing the Toy Soldiers package which many believed would be unbeatable. When the curtained opened and the MOH sang the intro to the ballad, the contest was already over. Members of TNT commented, "When the Masters sang their first line "I wander on as in a dream..." their sound was so full, clean and musical we knew they had won." The ballad became one of the highest scoring songs ever in International competition and solidified a third championship for the Masters of Harmony. A month later Dr. Lyne did indeed step down as director of the chorus.



Just A Baby's Prayer At Twilight- The New Tradition (1993-2nd) Between 1988 and 1992 The New Tradition had been floating anywhere from 3rd to 5th place in the International competitions. While their musical quality was good they had yet to break into the level of "elite chorus." Not until 1993 when they first introduced their Soldier's package in Calgary, Alberta. The first song was a hair-raising arrangement of "There's Something About A Soldier" with waving flags, trumpets and precision stage presence. The biggest surprise came when the front row turned into a drill rifle unit, spinning and tossing their rifles into the air with perfect execution. Having grabbed the audience's attention with this impactful uptune, the chorus suddenly switched gears by introducing a little boy who walked onstage to greet his father. The father takes a moment to speak with his son, gives him a hug then walks offstage, presumably to fight in a war. The son then gets down on his knees and prays as the chorus sings "Just A Baby's Prayer At Twilight." During the song the boy plays soldier and imitates his dad marching and aiming his rifle "longing to be a man." The emotion is raised when a lone soldier comes out to meet the boy. The boy runs to the man thinking it's his father, however is surprised to see that it's a stranger who is holding a folded American flag in his hands. The soldier presents the flag to the boy and salutes him with the most powerful stare I have ever seen. The boy cries for a moment, composes himself and at the end of the song stands tall and slowly raising his hand in a salute to his father. This set was the beginning of many theatrical performances TNT would bring to the contest stage.



Waiting For The Robert E. Lee- The Vocal Majority (1988-1st) Many would consider this song to be the birth of the "power uptune" in barbershop competitions. At the International Convention in San Antonio, TX, the Society was celebrating its 50th Anniversary. It was also finishing out the second year of an experimental exercise in what was called the Super Finals of chorus competition. Attempting to mimic the Sweet Adeline competition format, the Society created a finals round which allowed the top six choruses from the semifinals to compete again on Saturday evening. The year prior, the West Towns Chorus put the new format to the test by winning the International competition but never placing higher than second in both rounds. The Vocal Majority was expected to romp through the competitions, however a stubborn opponent in the Louisville Thoroughbreds thought differently about handing this contest to the VM. After the first round there was only a ten point spread between the two choruses. Disappointed in their performance, rumor has it VM director Jim Clancy called a late night rehearsal which lasted FIVE hours! The work paid off as the Vocal Majority slammed the competition with "Girl of My Dreams" and "Robert E. Lee." The apex of the uptune was when the chorus did a slow motion wave that oozed energy and creativity. With a driving tag, the chorus nailed the coffin door shut and won their fifth International championship. The uptune also paid dividends to its arranger. After this performance, David Wright became a household name in the barbershop world. Over twenty years later Robert E. Lee still holds itself up to current day competitions and the arrangement is virtually never performed by other music groups. Why fool around with perfection?


4 comments:

Joe Mathieu said...

"Robert E. Lee" MUST at the very least get past the first round. It's one performance that I will never forget.

liz garnett said...

Hi there,
Could you possibly list the arrangers for these songs? You've credited David Wright with three of them, and I think there's at least two more that are his. I'm guessing the New Tradition one would be Jay Giallombardo (but would like to know for sure), and I know that Brother Can You Spare a Dime is Steve Armstrong.

But the arrangement is such a key ingredient to these stunning performances, and I think it's so interesting that one arranger is so dominant - so it's only right that we know who else is holding their own in the Wright era!

Thank you,
liz

Mark Holdeman said...

Liz, I believe this is correct:

1. 76 Trombones - David Wright
2. Strike Up The Band/Everybody Step Medley - Aaron Dale
3. Song for the Little Guy - Steve Armstrong
4. Here Comes The Showboat - David Wright
5. Brother Can You Spare a Dime - Steve Armstrong
6. Love Me and the World Is Mine - David Wright

7. Just a Baby's Prayer at Twilight - Jay Giallombardo
8. Waitin' For The Robert E Lee - David Wright

Dennis Driscoll said...

Pardon the dissenting view, but I would ask you all to consider what we're asked to do. These are our criteria:

(1) performances that we would consider monumental (in influencing) the artistic direction of our art form; and
(2) broadened our creativity to help bring more diversity to the contest stage; and
(3) had the largest impact on our barbershop culture.

Wouldn't we agree that this does not necessarily mean performances for which the applause was the most enthusiastic and prolonged, nor even the most memorable. This is not a popularity contest in which devotees are, essentially, asked to vote for their home-town favorites.

And, given these commandments, how could we possibly nominate any performance as recent as those of the 1990's? I'd suggest that there simply hasn't been time enough to determine the legacy of such recent events.

May I suggest, then, that we consider

(1) The Louisville thoroughbreds performance
(was it 1966?) of "South Rampart Street Parade;" or,
(2) The year (1965) the Miamians actually moved from riser positions to the front of the stage. Now THAT was precedent setting!

I'm sure there a several others equally as formative. Given this more appropriate perspective, what do you think?

I don't mean for a moment to disparage the eight candidate performances; in every respect they
were better both aurally and visually than anything we've seen. But "impact," "broaden creativity," "impact our culture"? I think not.

Dennis Driscoll
Member since 1948.